The Changing American Campus

Table of Contents

In Essence

Bringing Back "The Tax To End All Taxes: Where Is Henry George Now That We Need Him?" by David Hapgood, in American Heritage 'Single Tax" (April-May 1978), 383 West Center St.,
Marion, Ohio 43302.

"Leaders Sans Troupes: Diregeants Noirs The Disenchanted et Masses Noirs" by Laura Armand-Maslow, in Revue Francaise de Science lack Voter Politique (Feb. 1978), 27 rue Saint Guil-laume, 75341, Paris.

"Buggings, Break-Ins & the FBI" by
James 0.Wilson, in Commentary (June
1978), 165 E. 56th St., New York, N.Y.
10022.

"How to Terminate a Public Policy: A Dozen Hints for the Would-be Ter-minator" by Robert D. Behn, in Policy Analysis (Summer 1978), University of California Press, Berkeley, Calif. 94720.

the Law Enforcement Assistance Administration and 10 percent to the Bureau of Prisons. Arguing that "public confidence in the impartial administration of justice is wan- ing," Rogovin would also separate the Department from all correc- tional functions and from the politics of grant-making.
Keeping The Books
 "Are We Starving Our Libraries?" Clint Page, in Nation's Cities (July 1978), 1620 Eye St. N.W., Washington, D.C. 20006.
Across the United States, urban libraries...

Paul Hollander, in Worldview ate (June 1978), P.O. Box 986, Farmingdale,
N.Y. 11735.
The United States has been the subject of more denunciation, hostility, and abuse foreign ideologues and intellectuals than any other nation in the world.
Hollander, a University of Massachusetts sociologist, attributes this worldwide animosity to America's affluence, its pervasive cultural presence (which, thanks to American movies, magazines, and television, extends through much of the world), and the recent...

Donald E.Weatherbee, in Asian
Survey (April 1978), University of Califor- of Imagination nia Press, Berkeley, Calif. 94720.
Since the end of the Indochina war, the members of the anticommunist Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN)-Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Thailand, and Singapore-have sought to develop a "regional resilience" to the threat of communist subversion. It is an effort that depends on Western and-as yet, uncertain-American eco-nomic, political, and military...

Steven J. Rosen, in Interna-Without Gain tional Security (Spring 1978), 9 Divinity
St., Cambridge, Mass. 02138.
As the euphoria surrounding the 1977 autumn peace initiative Egypt's President Anwar Sadat began to subside, there was speculation in Washington about the possibility of a fifth Arab-Israeli war. Such a struggle, says Rosen, Senior Research Fellow at Australia's National University, would result in a decisive Israeli battlefield victory, but no political or diplomatic gains for either...

removing a crucial personality but to draw attention to an issue killing a re- nowned figure," says Alder. The common element in both cases was "systemic frustration1'-an inability to arouse public feeling in support of an ideology (one nationalist, the other pacifist). Desperation led them to employ assassination-the act of "ultimate political pressurep'- which had significant long-range results that they never anticipated.
Reviewing "Bearing The Burden: A Critical Look at
JFK's...

Tracy Early; "Part 11: A corn-mitment Sustained" bv Patricia Derian, in Worldview (JUN-AUG.1978), P.O. Box 986, Farmingdale, N.Y. 11735.
 
President Carter's human rights crusade has been abandoned, says Early, a New York writer, because "it endangered too many American interests without visibly weakening tyrannies abroad." Reduced to ab- surdity, "the crusade now amounts to looking at 105 countries receiv- ing American aid or buying American weapons and finally deciding...

Lynn Advocacy, Inc. Adkins, in Dun's Review (June 1978), 666
Fifth Ave., New York, N.Y. 10019.
During the late 1960s and early 1970s, along with other U.S. insti- tutions, Big Business was subjected to severe press criticism, public skepticism, and increased federal regulation. A few corporation man- agers turned to advocacy advertising in responsedither to upgrade their "image" or to speak out on major business-related issues.
Mobil Corp., with $4 million budgeted for such advertising...

Lynn Advocacy, Inc. Adkins, in Dun's Review (June 1978), 666
Fifth Ave., New York, N.Y. 10019.
During the late 1960s and early 1970s, along with other U.S. insti- tutions, Big Business was subjected to severe press criticism, public skepticism, and increased federal regulation. A few corporation man- agers turned to advocacy advertising in responsedither to upgrade their "image" or to speak out on major business-related issues.
Mobil Corp., with $4 million budgeted for such advertising...

many Americans, these jobs are attractive to the illegal aliens moving in at the bottom of the wage structure.
Nevertheless, Wachter argues, available statistics suggest that about 50 percent of all illegal aliens earn wages at or above the legal mini- mum. Assuming that illegal aliens constitute 30 percent of the nation's lowest-skilled labor, if all of them were forced to leave the country, wages at the bottom of the job ladder would be driven up. Of the estimated 6 million jobs now held illegal...

they suggest that the working woman is generally happier and more satisfied with her life than the woman who does not work. But some of these findings, says Wright, of the Social and Demographic Research Institute at the University of Massachusetts, have been based on only a small sampling of predominantly working-class women.
Analyzing data from broader surveys conducted the National Opinion Research Center, Wright finds that working women "typically carry the double burden of work and...

the National Opinion Research Center, Wright finds that working women "typically carry the double burden of work and household commitments." They may enjoy their outside earned income and increased independence, but "pay for these benefits in reduced free time for themselves, a more hectic pace, and a more complicated life."
Surprisingly, neither working women nor housewives express much "outright dislike" for housework; and Wright's analysis of overall hap- piness,...

the cities' regular car- riers with no additional premiums. More difficult to overcome is the popular resistance in low-income areas, where residents say they al- ready have enough shacks and junk (they want asphalt playgrounds and concrete turtles). And disputes persist among recreation officials over what properly constitutes "play" in a technological, urban society.
Fear and Loathing "Analysis and Critique of HEW'S Safe sciimi study wort to the ~oups~
in the Classroom Robert...

Thomas Samaras, in The Futurist (August 1978), World Fu-

Beautiful
ture Society, P.O. Box 30369, Bethesda Branch, Washington, D.C. 20014.

The ever-increasing stature and size of North American and North European people has long been regarded as a good thing-a result of prosperity, better diet, and superior medical care. However, in ecologi- cal terms, human bigness is unquestionably bad.
So writes Samaras, a California systems analyst. Short people re- quire less food, oxygen...

Diana Crane, in Annals of the
American Academy (May 1978), 3937
Chestnut St., Philadelphia, Pa. 19104.
American physicians are moving toward a social definition of "life1'- defining an individual as being alive in terms of his ability to interact with others, rather than purely physical criteria.
Questioning more than 3,000 neurosurgeons, pediatric heart sur-geons, internists, and pediatricians, University of Pennsylvania sociol- ogist Crane found that most physicians (75 percent) agreed...

Diana Crane, in Annals of the
American Academy (May 1978), 3937
Chestnut St., Philadelphia, Pa. 19104.
American physicians are moving toward a social definition of "life1'- defining an individual as being alive in terms of his ability to interact with others, rather than purely physical criteria.
Questioning more than 3,000 neurosurgeons, pediatric heart sur-geons, internists, and pediatricians, University of Pennsylvania sociol- ogist Crane found that most physicians (75 percent) agreed...

the news media, the American public was treated to little more than misleading stories that "misinterpreted public opinion polls, focused on the personal contest . . .between the President and Senate leaders, and culminated in pious warnings that the treaties were not all that significant after all. . . ." Moreover, the media failed to tell the public much of anything about Panama and why the Panamanians had strug- gled for years to obtain the treaties giving them de jure independence...

the press for the expansion of its liberties and its right of inquisition surely contributes to the erosion of privacy and emphasizes the need for protection."
Miller applauds those statutes~opposed newsmen-that protect individuals from unwarranted public attention (i.e., laws prohibiting the naming of rape victims and restricting the release of certain crimi- nal records). He particularly objects to the zeal of gossip columnists and the revelation of private details of a person's life without...

its comprehensive belief system and the absence of meaningful alterna- tives. "To argue that the Moonist solution is inane, preposterous, or unrealistic is hardly a substitute for our not having any specific vision of the future," says Sandon.
The Moonies have rejected contemporary permissiveness for a rigor- ous morality, a spirituality characterized a "robust prayer life and a liturgical orderliness seldom found in conventional American religious life," and a communal lifestyle...

Cardinal Alfredo Ottaviani and his conservative associates in the papal curia during Vatican Council II (1964) in oppos- ing any change in the Church's moral and doctrinal teachings, the Council provoked a deeper examination of human sexuality and a closer look at the Church's views on the subject. So writes Father Mur- phy, rector of Holy Redeemer College in Washington, D.C.
Much of the confusion now surrounding Catholic teachings on con-
jugal love springs from the mistaken notion that the basic...

Wade Clark Religious Roof, in Society (May-June 1978), Box A, fistkssness Rutgers University, New Brunswick, N.J.
08903.
The rising popularity of many new religious and quasi-religious groups in America reflects a larger disarray. Many Americans are abandoning their earlier religious identities, writes Roof, a University of Massachu- setts sociologist.
Surveys the National Opinion Research Center show that religious defection is occurring primarily among the young (the proportions for liberal...

Wade Clark Religious Roof, in Society (May-June 1978), Box A, fistkssness Rutgers University, New Brunswick, N.J.
08903.
The rising popularity of many new religious and quasi-religious groups in America reflects a larger disarray. Many Americans are abandoning their earlier religious identities, writes Roof, a University of Massachu- setts sociologist.
Surveys the National Opinion Research Center show that religious defection is occurring primarily among the young (the proportions for liberal...

PERIODICALS
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
ions-molecules of common atmospheric gases that have taken on a positive or negative electrical charge.
The effects of air ions on living matter (including bacteria, plants, and human beings) are readily apparent but not thoroughly under- stood, write Krueger, a biometeorologist, and Sigel, a psychologist, both of the University of California at Berkeley. It is known, for exam- ple, that depletion of ions in the air may increase susceptibility to respiratory infec...

Frederick P. Schn~itt, in
Gulf Stream Oceans (May-June 1978), Oceanic Soci- ety, Fort Mason, San Francisco, Calif. 94123.
Ben Franklin, America's Renaissance man, was the first person to map the waters of the Gulf Stream, gleaning data on the great "ocean river" from his own scientific observations and the whaling experience of a Nantucket sea captain.
Franklin's interest in the "Gulph Stream," writes Schmitt, curator of the Whaling Museum at Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y., was...

PERIODICALS
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
Nantucket whaling
captains gave Ben
Franklin the data to
prepare this 1769 chart
of the "Gulph Stream."
Courtesy of the American Philosophical Society
to determine exactly when they entered or passed through the stream.
Franklin found 18th-century mariners reluctant to take advice from a
landsman. Modern day scientists, Schmitt observes, recently employed
satellite photographs-not Franklin's charts-in a study aimed at per-
suading capta...

Jon B.
rtful Origins Eklund, in Chemical and Eneineerine
News (June 5, 1978), American Chemical
of Knowledge Society, 1155 16th St. N.W., Washington,
D.C. 20036.
As a general rule, "pure" science discoveries are later elaborated engineers and other technicians as "applied" science. However, says Eklund, curator of chemistry at the Smithsonian Institution's National Museum of History and Technology, the reverse is often the case; a broad body of empirical knowledge is developed...

Calvin Martin, in Natural History
(June-July 1978), Box 6000, Des Moines,
Iowa 50340.
The wre-modern American Indian is widelv viewed as a noble savase
"
who lived in harmonious balance with nature, taking from it only what necessity demanded and respecting animals and plants as fellow spiritual beings. A new look at the historical record Martin, a Rut- gers historian, shows that at certain periods the Indian perceived his relationship with nature to have gone awry and engaged in a fearful...

Calvin Martin, in Natural History
(June-July 1978), Box 6000, Des Moines,
Iowa 50340.
The wre-modern American Indian is widelv viewed as a noble savase
"
who lived in harmonious balance with nature, taking from it only what necessity demanded and respecting animals and plants as fellow spiritual beings. A new look at the historical record Martin, a Rut- gers historian, shows that at certain periods the Indian perceived his relationship with nature to have gone awry and engaged in a fearful...

Richard A. Kenchington, in Environmental Conserva- tion (Spring 1978), Elsevier Sequoia, S.A.,
P.O. Box 851, 1001 Lausanne 1, Switzer- land.
Inadequate research, poor sampling techniques, and the eagerness of the news media for a sensational story combined to create the great crown-of-thorns starfish "menace" of the late 1960s and early '70s.
So says Australian marine biologist Kenchington, who suggests that the advent of scuba-diving technology led to greatly increased explora- tion...

human tam- pering with the environment. Subsequent surveys, which were inade- quately financed and hampered the extent and remoteness of the rich coral cover, did little to discourage speculation by the news media and environmentalists that the Great Barrier Reef would eventually collapse, exposing the entire Queensland coast to the erosive force of the Pacific Ocean.
In the absence of effective means of dealing with the menace (hand collecting and chemical treatment proved either impractical or...

the U.S. fleet to 0.26 per ton in 1977. This death toll is low enough to permit porpoise populations to increase, and, while the matter may continue to be debated in emo- tional terms, the authors cautiously conclude that porpoise deaths are "perhaps no longer a major ecological problem."
"The Real Meaning of the Energy Crunch" bv Daniel Yerein, in The New

Conservation York ~irnes~a~azine
(~une.4, 1978), 229
W. 43rd St., New York, N.Y. 10036.
A serious real energy crisi...

Steve Law- son, in Horizon (June 1978), 381 West Center Court, Marion, Ohio 43302.
A "Third Wave" of audacious and innovative British playwrights is beginning to make its mark on the English theater. These writers- Stephen Poliakoff, Barrie Keefe, Snoo Wilson, Steve Gooch-were spawned in small, makeshift theaters that have sprung up in Edin- burgh, Glasgow, Sheffield, and Liverpool as well as in London.
"Young, committed, and astonishingly prolific," the Third Wave dramatists,...

Steve Law- son, in Horizon (June 1978), 381 West Center Court, Marion, Ohio 43302.
A "Third Wave" of audacious and innovative British playwrights is beginning to make its mark on the English theater. These writers- Stephen Poliakoff, Barrie Keefe, Snoo Wilson, Steve Gooch-were spawned in small, makeshift theaters that have sprung up in Edin- burgh, Glasgow, Sheffield, and Liverpool as well as in London.
"Young, committed, and astonishingly prolific," the Third Wave dramatists,...

spraying acid on stretched nylon, Metzger created art that destroyed itself in the very act of creation. In using violence creatively without producing a commodity for the mar-ketplace, Walker argues, Metzger attained the elusive unity of art and politics that earlier anarchists had sought.
"Centrality Without Philosophy: The Crisis In The Arts" Joseph Wesley Zeigler, in New York Affairs (vol. 4, no. 4, 1978). New York University, Graduate School of Public ~dministration, 4 Wash-ington...

William Haley, in The American Scholar (Summer 1978), 1811 Q St. N.W., Wash- ington, D.C.20009.
England has fallen from its imperial heights as rapidly as any nation in history. Prime Minister James Callaghan's Labor Party government currently faces grave labor agitation and economic woes, friction with its European Common Market partners, and pressure to give autonomy to Scotland and Wales.
But, although Britain seems to be teetering on the brink of ruin, it will survive, says Haley, former director-general...

Correlli Bar- nett, in TheIllustrated London News (May or Genius? 1978). British Publications Inc.. 11-03
46th Ave., Long Island City, N.Y. 11 101. Napoleon Bonaparte, Emperor of France, was a master of modern pub- lic relations who brilliantly portrayed himself as a national hero and military genius. In reality, argues Barnett, author of the new biography Bonaparte, Napoleon "was not a heroic genius or a master of war at all, but an overconfident gambler pursuing a fundamentally unsound sys-...

Correlli Bar- nett, in TheIllustrated London News (May or Genius? 1978). British Publications Inc.. 11-03
46th Ave., Long Island City, N.Y. 11 101. Napoleon Bonaparte, Emperor of France, was a master of modern pub- lic relations who brilliantly portrayed himself as a national hero and military genius. In reality, argues Barnett, author of the new biography Bonaparte, Napoleon "was not a heroic genius or a master of war at all, but an overconfident gambler pursuing a fundamentally unsound sys-...

producing an end to detente and a return to the Cold War. Detente, contends Cook, permits the Russians to pursue other world ventures without risk and encourages the West- em trade and credits essential to the economic well-being of Eastern Europe.
Since the election defeat, Cook writes, "Marchais has dropped all the cosmetics and returned to his true Stalinist colors-to thi irrita- tion and bitterness of comrades who really believed in Eurocommu- nism. . . ." The French Communist Party...

the small but powerful group of people (blacks as well as whites) who do well under the exist- ing system. Riddell concludes that the Ian Smith option entails little structural change, and thus offers little chance of solving basic eco- nomic inequities. The Popular Front option presents huge short-term problems but does address the needs of the poor majority, and "holds out the greatest hope for the war-weary Zimbabweans."
"Between Repression and Reform: A Stranger's Impressions...

the small but powerful group of people (blacks as well as whites) who do well under the exist- ing system. Riddell concludes that the Ian Smith option entails little structural change, and thus offers little chance of solving basic eco- nomic inequities. The Popular Front option presents huge short-term problems but does address the needs of the poor majority, and "holds out the greatest hope for the war-weary Zimbabweans."
"Between Repression and Reform: A Stranger's Impressions...

Book Reviews

by Dierdre Bair
Harcourt, 1978
736 pp. $19.95
L of C 77-92527

by David and Marina
Ottaway
Holmes & Meier, 1978
224 pp. $20 cloth, $10 paper
L of C 77-28370
ISBN 0-8419-0363-8 paper

by James Webb
Prentice-Hall, 197
344 pp. $9.95
LofC78-4046

Essays

David Riesman
In common parlance, "the 1960s" generally denotes the tumultuous period between the Kennedy assassination in 1963 and the beginning of Watergate in 1972. Like other stereotypical decades, the '60s are now seen retrospectively through a dis- torted lens. We forget, for example, that civil-rights activism, civil disobedience, and the antinuclear movement in the United States all began in the 1950s. the same token, although Amer- ican campuses achieved their greatest visibility...

In common parlance, "the 1960s" generally denotes the tumultuous period between the Kennedy assassination in 1963 and the beginning of Watergate in 1972. Like other stereotypical decades, the '60s are now seen retrospectively through a dis- torted lens. We forget, for example, that civil-rights activism, civil disobedience, and the antinuclear movement in the United States all began in the 1950s. By the same token, although Amer- ican campuses achieved their greatest visibility in the...

David Riesman

There are perhaps 50 "elite" colleges and universities among the 3,000 institutions of higher education in the United States. They are, as their brochures plainly admit, highly selec- tive; 3 out of 4 applicants for admission regularly fail to pass through the needle's eye. They are also expensive: $8,000 or more for a year in collegiate heaven. A few of them (such as the University of California at Berkeley) are public schools, the flag- ship campuses of state institutions. But most...

Martin Kaplan

Community colleges, which now enroll about one-third of the country's 11 million undergraduates, crowd the very bottom of higher education's pecking order. Ranking below even the least prestigious of the four-year colleges and universities, these two-year schools struggle along without the assets that make for high intellectual status.
First of all, they are completely nonexclusive, admitting vir- tually anyone who walks through their doors. Their students usually have average academic preparation-or...

Larry Van Dyne

Everyone is familiar with certain claims made for American higher education: It is the largest and most equitable system in the world; its research and scholarship are unsurpassed; it is the engine driving the American Dream Machine. And indeed, it is all these things.

Chester E. Finn, Jr.

the early 20th century, first- rate research universities rivaling their European models.
From the start, campus debate has been vigorous-over academic free- dom, admissions policy, the cur- riculum, research. Should Harvard tolerate heretics (Cotton Mather, 1702)? Are the classics an anach-ronism (The Yale Report, 1828)? Must the university deal with populist as well as aristocratic tastes (Ezra Cor- nell, 1865)?
In Laurence Veysey's view (The Emergence of the American Univer- sity, Chicago,...

Readers' letters to the editors of Soviet women's magazines depict a society where household appliances break down, hus- bands drink heavily, and the process of divorce is often costly and time-consuming; where wage scales are low, where child care conflicts with the need to work, and husbands refuse to help with the household chores.
One cartoon shows a frenzied wife, exhausted from eight hours on the job, hurrying to prepare her family's supper. The husband, in house slippers, lounges in front...

Bernice Madison

A RECURRING FEVER
Economists still haggle over a proper definition of inflation, but most Americans know inflation's impact: rising prices. From Kennedy to Nixon to Carter, Washington's stop-and-go anti- inflation strategies have proved inadequate. Here the editors outline the postwar record, and economist Laurence Seidman describes the latest proposed remedy.
According to Plutarch, Athens under Solon (fl. 600 B.c.) wrestled with severe inflation after depreciation of the mina. To restore stabi...

Laurence S. Seidman

decree. Since then, India has receded from the headlines (ex- cept during President Carter's flying visit last January). The na- tion's current economic and political health is relatively good, but the long-term outlook is a matter of dispute. We present here some diverse views. Former diplomat Edward O'Neill traces Indian-American relations since the bloody Moslem-Hindu Par- tition of the subcontinent in 1947; journalist B. G. Verghese looks at India's political history; and economist Lawrence...

*-=
Eighteen months ago, the West hailed India's return to democ- racy after Prime Minister Morarji Desai took office in the wake of voters' rejection of Indira Gandhi and her "Emergency" rule by decree. Since then, India has receded from the headlines (ex- cept during President Carter's flying visit last January). The na- tion's current economic and political health is relatively good, but the long-term outlook is a matter of dispute. We present here some diverse views. Former diplomat...

Edward A. O'Neill

n Parliament-and the Prime Minis- ter's office.
The Congress held the country together in 1948 during the appalling trauma of Partition, when millions of people moved between Hindu India and Muslim Pakistan and uncounted hun- dreds of thousands were slaughtered on the basis of their reli- gious faiths. The Congress shaped India's 1950 Constitution and established the democratic framework that its latter-day leader, Indira Gandhi, drastically abridged before she, and the party, were brought down...

B. G. Verghese

as a whole. It cuts through elegant quarters and crowded slums, through a seemingly endless variety of neighborhoods that re- flect India's sundry regions, religions, castes, and classes.
The daily traffic is an extraordinary mix: government offi- cials, diplomats, and business executives speeding through the dust in their limousines; fleets of aggressive, gaily painted trucks; a seemingly endless parade of bicyclists and pedestrians; and a slow circus procession of farmer's bullock carts, buffaloes,...

Lawrence A. Veit

the Archaeological Survey, which the British Viceroy, Lord Cur- zon, had reformed and enlarged in 1901.
Profiting from the digs at Mohenjo- Daro and Harappa, A. L. Basham's The Wonder That Was India: A Sur-vey of the Culture of the Indian Sub-continent Before the Coming of the Muslims (Grove, paper, 1954; Taplinger, cloth, 1968) begins the story 2,500 years before Christ. At that time the once-fertile Indus Val- ley in the northwest (today a part of Pakistan) already supported an ad- vanced pre-Aryan...

David Hapgood, in American Heritage 'Single Tax" (April-May 1978), 383 West Center St.,
Marion, Ohio 43302.
Henry George (1839-97), perhaps America's most innovative economic theorist, may have been right in his notion of taxing land rather than the improvements on land. So writes Hapgood, author and former journalist.
Living in California just 10 years after the Gold Rush (1849), George observed that land, once cheap, was quickly concentrated in a few hands and then held off the market...

Paul Gauguin. National Gallery ofAn, Washrigion, D.C., Chester Dale Collection.

The Wilson QuarterlyIAutumn 1978
166
The great canvases of Paul Gauguin (1848-1903) hang in the world's major museums-the Louvre, the Tate, New York's Met- ropolitan, Washington's National Gallery. His sculptures, ceramics, watercolors, and other works are in collections in cities as diverse as Moscow and Manchester, Stockholm and Indianapolis. Last year an 1894 Gauguin woodcut, Te Faruru- IdOn Fait L'Amour, sold...

The difference between a moral man and a man of honor is that the latter regrets a discreditable act even when it has worked and he has not been caught.
-H. L. Mencken
Seldom has a towering historical clude a prolonged correspondence personage been more successfully with Julia Sand, his 32-year-old con- veiled from posterity than Chester A. fidante from Brooklyn. He himself Arthur. "Chet" to his friends, the burnt the rest of his memorabilia- best-dressed man in Washington reason enough,...

Sybil Schwartz

Browse Our Issues