Safer Than 'Nam

Safer Than 'Nam

The new kind of war being fought in Iraq has resulted in much lower troop deaths compared to earlier conflicts, but woundings are still alarmingly high.

Read Time:
2m 30sec

It didn’t take a creative Hollywood scriptwriter to manufacture the dangers of operating a flamethrower during World War II. Lumbering across the battle­field with 70 pounds of weaponry strapped on their backs, silhouetted like the cartoon character SpongeBob SquarePants as they sought to get close enough to incinerate their targets, the men who wielded these weapons experienced legendary death ­rates. Tradi­tional flamethrowers are gone from the new kind of war being fought in Iraq, but fatality rates there are still vastly different from front to rear, mission to mis­sion, and rank to rank, write Emily Buz­zell, a graduate of the University of Pennsylvania now serving with AmeriCorps, and Samuel H. Preston, a demog­ra­pher on the university’s ­faculty.

Overall, the death rate of military personnel in Iraq is about four per 1,000 per year, roughly three times that of Americans of similar age at home. The Vietnam War mortality rate among American troops was nearly 22 per 1,000, five times that for the war in Iraq. The ratio of dead to wounded in Iraq is only about a third of what it was in Southeast Asia because wounded soldiers get faster and better care.

Reflecting the differences in ex­posure to combat, the Marine Corps death rate is double that of the Army, nine times higher than the Navy’s, and 23 times high­er than that of the Air Force. Among all service­mem­bers, the greatest danger in the war is faced by Marine lance ­corporals.

Active Army forces are three times more likely to die per deployment than are members of the Army Reserve. But Marines are at very high risk regardless of whether they are active-duty members or ­reservists.

Consistent with their official exclusion from primary combat positions, women have a mortality rate one-sixth that of men. Largely as a consequence of their lower rank, younger troops are more likely to die in the line of duty than older ones.

Hispanics face a higher risk of death in Iraq than ­non-­Hispanics. Blacks face less than whites. Part of the reason may be that they are overrep­resented in lower-risk categories: 19 percent of blacks in Iraq are women, compared with nine per­cent of ­non­blacks, and seven percent are Marines, compared with 11 percent of ­non­blacks, according to Buzzell and ­Preston.

Deaths in Iraq—2,706 at the time the authors compiled their data and 3,894 on December 19, 2007—are rare in comparison to woundings. From 2003 to the end of 2006, one of every 31 U.S. troops serving in Iraq was wounded. The pattern of woundings, Buzzell and Preston say,  is quite likely to be the same as the demographics of ­death.

THE SOURCE: “Mortality of American Troops in the Iraq War” by Emily Buzzell and Samuel H. Preston, in Population and Development Review, Sept. ­2007.

More From This Issue