Gotham's Melting Pot

Gotham's Melting Pot

Mimi Schwartz

Mimi Schwartz reviews a new guide to Queens, the largest of the city’s five boroughs and the second most populous (after Brooklyn). The book's author calls it “the most heterogeneous place in the world.”

Read Time:
3m 3sec


By Claudia Gryvatz Copquin. Yale Univ. Press. 265 pp. $­35

New York City, for many, means the borough of Manhattan, with its skyscrapers, Fifth Avenue shops, Central Park, and Wall Street. But just to the east is a lesser-known gem: Queens. The largest of the city’s five boroughs (110 square miles) and the second most populous (after Brooklyn), Queens is unique. It is, as historian Kenneth T. Jackson points out in his introduction to The Neighborhoods of Queens, “the most heterogeneous place in the world.” Of its two million residents, 44 per-cent are foreign ­born—­a population that tops Miami’s. One Queens neighborhood, Elm­hurst, has immigrants from 110 countries. Another, Astoria, “has the largest Greek population outside the Mediterranean.” Richmond Hill is home to the largest population of Sikhs outside India. And on it ­goes.

The Neighborhoods of Queens—written by Claudia Gryvatz Copquin, a free-lance journalist raised on the turf—is a practical, ­easy-­to-­use guide to every one of the 99 neighbor­hoods and smaller yet distinct ­sub-­neigh­bor­hoods of this fascinating, multi­cultural borough. Each chapter offers a brief narrative overview of the area it covers and is generously illus­trated with photographs and a detailed map. Before Yale launched its “Neighborhoods of New York City” series (in collaboration with the Citizens Committee for New York City), to which this book is the latest addition, no one had attempted to map all the city’s ­neighborhoods.

My family arrived in the borough as refu­gees from Nazi Germany in 1937, three years before I was born. I grew up in Forest Hills, and when I opened to the chapter on that neighborhood, there was a photo of the West Side Tennis Club, where we used to watch the U.S. Open before it moved to Flushing Meadows in 1978. Other pictures captured the mix of apartment houses and neat ­single-­family ­houses—­five or six to a ­block—­that I used to pass every day as a child. Across the dozen or so lanes of Queens Boule­vard is the more exclusive Forest Hills Gardens, the nation’s first planned community, designed by Frederick Law Olmsted Jr. and Grosvenor Atterbury in the early 1900s to look like a quaint English village. Jews and Catholics were not welcome there in my day, but when I walked in this neighborhood a few years ago, signs on tele­phone poles and lawns indicated the presence of a thriving Asian ­community.

Aside from its rich diversity, what makes Queens special is a tradition of tolerance that began more than a century before the Declar­ation of Independence. When the Dutch con­trolled the area in the 1600s, citizens revolted against Governor Peter Stuyvesant’s efforts to limit how they worshiped, producing the Flushing Remonstrance of 1657. This petition, Jack­son writes, “remains the most eloquent defense of religious freedom in all of American history.” One man, John Bowne, went to jail rather than sub­mit to a law that forbade Quakers from worshiping in his house. He appealed, and the Dutch government overruled Stuyvesant. It all hap­pened in Flushing, Queens, in what is now the heart of a thriving Chinatown. Bowne’s house, the oldest structure in the borough, has been converted to a museum on the street named after ­him.

Queens still attracts people looking for opportunity and peace. Despite its latest influx of diverse ­newcomers—­from China, Guyana, the Dominican Republic, Colombia, Jamaica, South Korea, India, Haiti, and ­Ecuador—­this borough of New York has fewer homicides than many American cities with smaller populations, including Atlanta and Baltimore. We should all go to Queens to see how it’s ­done.

More From This Issue